top of page
Search

'Those People'

Writer: Ann Johnson of Wave-length CIC
Ann Johnson of Wave-length CIC
Jul 8, 2020
6 min read

This is a personal viewpoint of Ann Johnson MD of Wave-length CIC


I am sure I am not the only person who when sometimes viewing strangers make up stories of their lives, I have always done it and thought of it as a creative way of thinking, but I am not consciously aware of it being based on stereotypes but might it be unconsciously? Much of my made-up stories are based on why they were alone today in the park? Where are they going with their family? Why haven’t they bought their picnic along? and they always become quite fantastical, but I have never taken time to reflect to heavy on this - am I ever being bias in my thoughts of the stranger? It is fair to say it is natural to do so and many times we do not know we are doing it, its shaped by our engagement with, understanding of and exposure to different people along with situations in our lives and can be influenced by many things including our family, the media and life’s experiences.



Where stereotypes can create real risk is when we apply them to decision making, when we hold influence and ultimately when we are in a position of power to choose, whether it is to recruit, select or support. In my own home, management position and leadership roles I have come across many examples of stereotyping and bias that without challenge could have resulted in or created potential discrimination.



My most recent experience of stereotyping happened last week and influenced the decision for this week’s blog. We have had some landscapers at our house re-inventing our garden space, the business is run by two guys one of which has a very strong south wales accent, which can sound to some to carry a hint of Irish, perhaps a natural mistake with both languages having Celtic origins, I made the same mistake initially only to correct myself as the welsh accent came through when chatting to him. I then met a friend last week who mentioned the same guy, ‘he is Irish’ they said, “I bet he has been a traveler’ they went on to say, ‘but all the same a nice guy’. So, it might be a mistake with the accent, but then why assume an Irish workman to be a traveler and then say he was nice, did they expect him not to be? And whilst this example did not have a direct impact on the landscaper it might be a factor on whether the friend would employ or recommend him to others.


There are many other examples I have experienced in the workplace, so have decided to include the ones that left me wondering the most.


When considering the health and safety of a group of people enjoying art weekly in our community space, I was surprised to hear one of the committee members say ‘the issue with those people ……’ What do you mean by the phrase those people I asked which was quantified by them being a group of people with physical disabilities ‘people like me’ I asked ‘this is not the same’ was the response. What did they mean not the same? Were ‘those people’ assumed to have other social challenges or simply seen by this person as different to them? The risk here is of course that they would be treated differently because of their condition, whereas the Equality Act 2010 built on the social model of disability does not ask what are the limitations of the group? instead it asks what do we have to do as an organisation to accommodate everyone who visits us.


But stereotyping of course is not just limited to the Irish and those with a disability (both run a risk of discrimination) but many other personal factors not always linked to protected characteristics. A few years ago we were offered the opportunity to deliver a summer children’s food programme offered to families on low incomes, I selected the best member of our staff team to deliver; a great cook, teacher and someone who loved being around children, so feeling I had things in place I sat with the co-delivery team, who have you chosen they said? I then mentioned the member of staff selected and they said do you think that’s a good choice? Are they the right person to lead and support the children on a food related project they asked, without any further clarity it left me a bit confused I said yes and reconfirmed that she has all the right qualities, which was then followed by ‘would not have been our obvious choice’ but happy to go with your decision. I drove home wondering whether I had missed anything? They did not know my staff that well, how could they have made a different choice? as I reached home the answer came to me, the woman I had chosen was obviously overweight perhaps termed as clinically obese, something that had not come into my decision making but obviously influenced the co-delivery partner. Had they seen her as a poor role model; someone who looked as if she ate too much or did not eat healthily? I am not sure but they knew nothing of her, about her life or any reasons that had led to being over-weight, it all seemed to be based on assumption. It was a delight to watch her with the children, they loved her and the food she cooked, so did the families – she was the right person for the job, but if left to others she would not have had the opportunity to do it.


So how much do we judge people? are your staff getting it right? I want to end on a recruitment example that will stay with me forever. I used to be a HR Director of a large company, as we grew in size we had a need to recruit for an Admin/Office Manager, following shortlisting and interviews there was two candidates left to decide upon, the decision in making the final offer for the post was troubling the interviewer so they came to see me for support and guidance. When I enquired of the concern, they said that the best candidate on paper had an impairment caused by arthritis that affected her hand ‘she has said she can do the job following a keyboard adjustment, but I am not convinced’ the interviewer said; I thought for a moment and responded with ‘so how are you so sure the other candidate can do the job’?’ The interviewer said thanks for helping me re frame the decision making and left my office. The issue here is we never really know who will be the best at the job, that’s why businesses should have strong recruitment policies and robust probation processes which should ultimately end on employing the person who is the right person for the job, not for us to judge if a person with a disability is telling us the truth or not about their capabilities. The right person for the job, was then employed, yes, she needed an adjusted keyboard (26.00) but she turned out to be an excellent choice, valued work colleague and remains a friend today.




Taking the examples above we should see that it is essential that organisations look at the conscious and unconscious risks they might face on daily basis, whether it results in the failure to choose the best person for the task, job or at worst a claim of discrimination. We need to ensure that our staff understand the risks associated with stereotyping, conscious and unconscious bias when making selections; the same should be applied to the way our policies address people we provide services to or support. We need also to consider the impact of wording and intentions used within our policies and communications, avoiding terms that label people or feed the conscious and unconscious bias and if you think this does not happen you only have to read the request made last week by Baroness Jane Campbell who calls for an end to use of ‘vulnerable ‘to describe people with disabilities, she said that many disabled people placed in the category of “vulnerable” or those who were told they needed to “shield” had been forced instead to campaign for their basic human rights throughout the pandemic because the concept of “vulnerability… simply serves to anonymise our humanity and human rights”.


Managers notes:

· Make sure your staff are aware of the risks of stereotyping, conscious and unconscious bias to your organisation *

· Have good reasonable adjustment policies and working practices to support people that join you*

· That the words you use in policies and communications do not negatively impact on others*

Notes followed by an * mean that at Wave-length we can assist you if you need it.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page