top of page
Search

Can online meetings pose a greater risk to bias an discrimination?

Writer: Ann Johnson of Wave-length CIC
Ann Johnson of Wave-length CIC
Jan 3, 2021
3 min read

I was asked recently by an organisation ‘are there any guides to running an online meeting? particularly around risks of inequality and exclusion’ having had a quick look I found there to be many around etiquette and planning an online meeting but none that directly looked at exclusion, discriminatory risks and how to mitigate them, so not surprisingly the organisation asked if I could research the topic, seek to see if there were risks of discrimination, inequality and exclusion that might not be prevalent in physical meetings.


I have to say at first I thought surely there are only benefits to this change in the way we meet, helping those with some physical conditions and those with caring responsibilities cut down the need to travel to and from meetings, but I discovered that while there are clearly many benefits related to business and people, there are risks in respect of discrimination especially related to race, religion, age, gender and disability all of which should be examined and mitigated when planning for a future that relies more heavily than ever on online meetings. Many of the risks now and due mainly to COVID 19 mean that instead of joining a meeting from our office desk we enter the meeting from our home which can be unpredictable, often informal and can create its own subtle exclusions and risks to harassment. The research work I had agreed to undertake was so interesting instead of the 8 hours I had set aside over the festive break I spent more like 16 hours getting hooked into reading research papers on the potential discriminatory risks and benefits to many groups of people when joining online meetings. (inc. the protected characteristics under the Equality Act)



For me personally I think meeting online has been a bit of a leveler, people who have not previously met me have not realised I use a wheelchair and so the height difference has not been an issue, people have probably noticed me more for what I contribute and have not seen my chair, perhaps some people would have felt the same. In fact, I joined a new committee initially via their online meeting programme and then when an opportunity allowed for a few of us to meet together in a local venue, one person saying ‘I had no idea you were a wheelchair user Ann’, surely that’s a good thing was my first thought and would it have made a difference was my second one. But for others online meetings will have surely come with anxiety, stress and fears around intrusion into their lifestyle, cultural beliefs and social environment.


I suspect for many organisations they have simply made a switch to online from physical meetings without assessment of equality imbalance, not creating a protocol/code of conduct or seeking to pro-active plan to improve inclusion. One organisation asked me a couple of months ago if I felt there was a greater risk to bias in online interviewing compared to physical interviews, my reply ‘it depends what your biases are’.


So, I guess the point of this reflection is that as with health and safety risk assessments we should similarly assess the risk to equality discrimination and seek opportunity to understand, seek to improve inclusion and remove the risk of discrimination and whilst such pro-activeness might not avoid a visit to an employment tribunal it might help identify training needs and help evidence your desire to get things right for your staff and/or those that engage with your organisation.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page