Surely, I am not the only one to have unconscious biases?

“They might have a degree but they have no common sense’ was a phrase my nan would often say as she employed part-time students at her fish and chip shop. Clearly a conscious bias but it never stopped her taking them on, she often attributed it to the fact that they might be bright but not know how to fry the chips or clean a surface down. Nan passed away years ago but her phrase came back to me many years later when I had the pleasure to work with an Irish politician, someone who seemed so academically bright that you felt in project meetings he knew everything, if there was a question to be asked he was the guy and of course if I was stuck on part of the programme I went to him for the answer. Then one day we as we were all to meet in London and I met him at the station to take the tube together, I was amazed that this informed politician did not seem able to follow a simply instruction to purchase his tube ticket something I had become used to. This incident reminded me instantly of nan and the chips, it caused me to reflect more on what I had relied on him to provide into the project, believing him to know the answer. This type of unconscious bias is referred to as a halo effect defined as assuming that because someone is good at one thing, they will be equally good at another. A lesson learnt for me and something I am now acutely aware of in my working life, reminding myself to question, research and seek other opinions when working on projects with others.

There is real keen interest at the moment in unconscious bias and its impact in the workplace, a subject I find fascinating as it has so many dimensions to reflect upon, in fact depending on the sources you read there is 5-12 different types of bias, all helping you to understand how it might impact on you at work, on a board/committee or the way you perceive your environment.
This week as I ring-fence time to complete the session plan for my next unconscious bias online course, tweaking it to reflect the needs of managers in the UK hairdressing sector I thought I would share some of my own personal thoughts and experiences on this fascinating topic.
Taken that we might already know the difference between the conscious and unconscious bias, the first being something we knowingly do and the latter doing without knowing, then the art of removing risk from our biases must be making the unconscious conscious but its not that easy.
Its natural to have unconscious biases influenced by so many things around us, our childhood, the media and our experiences, the trick remains being aware of them and reflecting upon them. So for example; when I have been asked to be on a recruitment panel I have occasionally found myself listening to a person but no longer hearing them, I am already beginning to judge them and their fit for the job before they have answered all the questions, the risk here is that I am demonstrating a bias, perhaps one of “affinity bias” where I cannot connect with the person and I am interviewing. So now when I become aware of this behaviour, I press the mental pause button and say to myself ‘why am I thinking this way’ what is happening to my thought process? what evidence do I have to support my way of thinking (if any)? I could of course be right and the person is not displaying the right values for the role, but it is worth checking first that an unconscious bias is not getting in the way of recruitment in an organisation, this can be achieved by awareness of bias in the system, robust scoring methods, along with discussion post recruitment to ascertain why people have given the scores they have.

Opposite to the Halo effect is the Horn effect, which unlike the faith I had given in the politician above it can mean that due to one negative trait in someone you begin to unconsciously dismiss or see positive attributes or contributions the person can make to the team, for me it brings to mind someone I used to be on a board with who had a question or comment to make to every item or point raised on the agenda raised, so much so that I had begun to unconsciously switch off to him, “here he is again” I am sure my mind was saying. With the benefit of the way unconscious bias works I can now stop and reflect on this situation and the way my mind is working. It can be hard to realise and understand the impact on this type of often unseen bias and the way it can slowly and unconsciously undermine productive workplaces, what if my dismissal of input was to a manager, close work colleague, someone who had the answer I was looking for?
Affinity bias is probably the bias we can relate to the most, where we feel most comfortable with those, we share an affinity with, whether the same age, ethnicity, from an area we are familiar with or from the same college. It is well documented that the human brain can decide whether we are going to get along with someone in seconds of meeting them, which over time, working alongside them might change and, in many cases, make little difference to our lives, but what if we use this to form a decision to employ someone? Then we create organisations and teams that are lacking in diversity, knowledge and ability to challenge. Just stop now and think of the make-up of your closest friends to test the theory of affinity bias, of my trusted 6 friends; 5 are white and only 2 male.
Understanding that we all have unconscious biases the trick then is to become aware of them, understand them, look at ways to find them and reduce them. Perhaps the simplest method is to ‘take 5’ think before you make a decision, question your evidence, knowledge, research, fear or concern; stop and wonder about why you are feeling or responding in this way to a situation. I have also begun to consciously test myself and any bias I might have, for example: each early morning with the first tea of the day, I have for many years searched out the BBC News website and read through the overnight news around the world, unconsciously clicking on stories and images that interest me, but now after reading them I ask myself why did I choose that one and not that one? What encouraged me to open that news item? Often I discover its an affinity with the story, one of family, a murder, high profile court case; a topic I am interested in, but this of course limits my knowledge and could be creating unconscious bias to people and events that I feel do not align with me and my life, so I begin now to look for something further to read, something from the world news or a story where I see no images to influence my decision to open the story - just a headline.
I can only conclude that part of the trick of making the unconscious bias conscious is asking yourself, why am I thinking in this way? Why did I come to that conclusion? What or who is influencing my decision? Failing to recognise the risks of unconscious bias does not just have an impact on us personally but it can have a huge impact on the company we work for, in recruitment, selection and decision making. So, if you are a CEO or manager, make sure that its not just your unconscious bias kept under review but also that of your team, as left unnoticed your organisations effectiveness could be seriously impacted upon.
Managers notes:
· Check working practices for potential bias i.e. recruitment panels, decision panels, boards etc. *
· Do your managers, board members understand the breadth and impact of unconscious bias? *
· Do processes and projects provide enough time to seek and evidence decision making?
Notes followed by an * mean that at Wave-length we can assist you if you need it.




Comments