Equality Impact Assessments do they still serve a purpose?

Today I have been mapping out an online Equality Impact Assessment (EIA) training session for a public sector organisation. When chatting to them about what they wanted from the training, the group work and support into their strategic inclusion plans their response was we simply want ‘help in filling the organisations forms’. This took me a little by surprise because I am a firm believer that the form is the easy bit, it’s the equality and social inclusion knowledge, research and acknowledgement of support needed to complete the form is the hard bit. If you have prepped well then, the form is easy.
The hard part of any assessment of risk, whether positive, neutral or negative is deciding what the risks might look like, who might a decision or change impact upon? And why, how, when and how could the risk be mitigated or reviewed? and how do you know what you do not know. I spoke to an organisation recently who said that they moved to new offices and yes they admitted they had failed to do a thorough EIA, the move went well, great office site, but the organisation realised once the papers had been signed that there was no public transport to the new offices. This impacted on some members of staff unable to drive for varying reasons, all of whom are now feeling that their needs are not valued by the organisation. This example now has financial and moral costs, if only they had carried out an EIA at the start of the idea to move, given time to reflect, time in which this would have easily jumped out at someone, perhaps even others positive and negative impacts that are not so easy to predict.

Several years ago, I was asked to help support an EIA on a hospital move and to facilitate some of the consultations. They asked me to focus on transgender need and impact, of course I said yes but at the same time felt that this was probably not needed and that it would be likely that the impact would be neutral, that’s a decision I presumed before I had even started the consultation. To meet the need I contacted people I knew already who had changed gender and asked if they were able to meet me for coffee with other contacts to chat about the hospital move. This resulted in around 6 people coming together to discuss the impact on a hospital move, I opened with the purpose of an EIA, went through the proposed changes and provided some areas to consider. I then handed it over to them, the area of discussion was not what I had anticipated, the questions came and the key one response was how long would any proposed bus journey be? ‘why?” I asked, well the longer I sit on a bus the longer I am stared at, victimised and ridiculed was the response. This highlighted to me an unacceptable situation that some of this group experienced, felt and feared, something I could not have guessed had I simply been filling in a form in my office, without my part of a larger EIA the perceived impact would have stayed unknown and no mitigation or review would have been put in place. How can we understand the impact on our companies polices, procedures and plans for change if we are not seeking to understand how the outcome or working practice will impact on them.
Other business activities left unchecked can also create challenges they might include our websites etc. taking time out to assess equality and diversity can help you reflect on accessibility v usability of digital and IT services and whether the latter might be the more useful for your applications.
EIA’s prompt you to consult on the various options and assist you in coming to the right decisions and whilst EIA’s are a suggested tool for meeting the public sector Equality Duty, it can be a great method for all organisations to evidence compliance with the Equality Act and to ensure that they do not waste precious resources by retro fitting services after they have been put in place.

It can also help us meet the Equality Act 2010 requirement to consider anticipatory adjustment need; meaning that you should not wait until an adjustment is requested to apply it, you are expected to anticipate that it might be required in the future.
Returning from furlough would be a good time to carryout an EIA so as to understand and mitigate risks linked to staff settling back into the workplace; perhaps considering reasonable adjustments, mental well-being and carers needs. I spoke to one organisation I am currently supporting and they said they would know who to offer return to work post furlough sessions to, I questioned this, as sometimes we cannot assume who will deal well when returning to work and who will not. So an EIA outcome was offering everyone coming off furlough to have a return to work meeting, saving the company time in the future, demonstrating their support to mental well-being for all and a chance to understand what concerns all staff have in returning back to the workplace.
Any change is important to assess and keeping in mind the example of the office move mentioned above, it reminded me of when in 2000 I was working for a company about to move only 6 miles away from their existing offices, it was agreed that I would meet with all staff to go over the move, a collective meeting to share the plans and then one 2 ones followed with every member of the workforce just to ask how they felt about the move, the positives they saw from it and the challenges they might face personally from it. For many the questions were quick and straight forward others shared concerns that would not have simply been able to assume, some wanted to come in a bit earlier/or later due to changed childcare arrangements, some now wanted to cycle racks, blue badge parking and others were simply anxious about change and valued the time to talk, a bit of effort at the time of change paid huge benefits to the organisation. As a result, the move went well, no need to make adjustments post move (all could be planned in advance) and all staff felt valued. This was a more inclusive approach and could be easily adopted for returning to work post furlough, in order to encourage and effectively support your team back to the workplace.
So if want to improve your Equality, Diversity and Inclusion planning from the top of the organisation through its about your commitment to do so that matters and not your ability to complete a form that matters.
So I feel there is a place for the Equality Impact Assessment or similar process, it gives time to consider changes being applied, it evidences legal compliance, it helps us reflect on equality impact on our staff and customers, it can help save the company money and it’s a great way of telling people you value them.
As I complete the EIA online training session, I might encourage the client to just hide the EIA form for the time being and concentrate on the value the process brings; the information, research and intelligence, they can always test filling in the form later.




Comments